Foreign Policy Blogs

Kazakhstan Passes New Internet Law

President Nursultan Nazarbaev recently signed a new law placing blogs, social media networks, and chatrooms under the rubric of “mass media”, effectively creating criminal liability for users of these internet communication platforms  and permitting the government to shut down and censor websites as it sees fit. The government denies this law as being any kind of tool for repression, framing the law as benefiting Kazakh citizens by granting protection from extremist literature, piracy, and 2009’s ultimate cliche excuse-pornography.

The Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) had urged Nazarbaev not to sign the law into effect. Miklos Haraszti, OSCE’s Representative on Freedom of the Media, criticized the legislation as contrary to both OSCE and international standards. Kazakhstan is set to chair OSCE in 2010-a decision that has been criticized by groups such as Human Rights Watch ever since the decision was made by OSCE’s council in 2007. Watchdog organizations have repeatedly questioned Kazakhstan’s ability to lead and uphold OSCE’s commitment to human and civic rights and the passing of this new internet law only reaffirms the apprehension.

Kazakhstan’s relationship with the internet is complex, with attempts to strengthen internet usage and boost the Kazakh telecommunications sector coexisting with efforts to monitor and suppress online content. Nazarbaev has been openly ambitious in regard to development of the Kazakh IT sector, which in the past decade has become the clear frontrunner and main internet service provider in Central Asia. That being said, online access is still accessible only to a minority, and Kazakh citizens living outside of major cities are well beyond the reach of the internet. Also, long before the enactment of the recent internet law plenty of legislation was already in place placing limitations on internet content (and aiding in the encouragement of self-censorship). More than 300 legislative acts exist that control information and telecommunications in Kazakhstan in one way or another. Although a few competitors do exist, Kazakhtelecom effectively holds a monopoly in the country and exerts an extraordinary amount of control. Traffic of all first-tier ISPs go through Kazakhtelecom’s channels, permitting an easy, centralized way to filter content. Furthermore, since Kazakhtelecom is the main provider of internet in countries like Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, and Tajikistan it censors content for its Central Asian neighbors as well.

In 2008, was blocked, with Kazakhtelecom denying any role in the matter. Oddly enough, the Russian-language version of the site, (which also happens to be the most popular blogsite in Russia), remained accessible. Speculation on behalf of media outlets such as The Moscow Times was that the block had to do with Nazarbaev’s former son-in-law, Rakhat Aliyev, who has openly criticized (and blogged about) the Nazarbaev government. Other websites such as Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty have been blocked since last year.

Add a comment

Comments (7)

  1. michaelt Sunday - 19 / 07 / 2009 Reply
    Excellent! Ban all Blogs, Face book and subversive internet sites.The subversive rubbish that is presented is a :Devide and conquer" tactic aranged by organizations like OSCE, United Nations, the Americans and British with their freedom of speech and their democrocy. I will also suggest that the western press must be banned, this being the hard copies as well as the versions on the internet.
  2. bathmateus Saturday - 26 / 12 / 2009 Reply
    this is nice article........ Bathmate
  3. webroyalty Tuesday - 05 / 01 / 2010 Reply
    interesting posting...........thanks for the information,keep up the good work.....
  4. webroyalty Friday - 15 / 01 / 2010 Reply
    U are always a good writer. The way u write is awesome. Webroyalty
  5. BoxScoottNaro Saturday - 08 / 01 / 2011 Reply
    Very informative post. Thanks for taking the time to share your view with us.


  1. […] to note – Governments can play the game too! In an effort to better manage control over the flow of information, Kazakhstan is setting precedence… Recent news leakage out of Iran is prompting other governments to start clamping down on potential […]

  2. […] Katya Fisher Yoffe reports that Kazakhstan president signed a new law placing blogs, social media networks, and chatrooms under the rubric of “mass media”, effectively creating criminal liability for users of these internet communication platforms and permitting the government to shut down and censor websites as it sees fit. Cancel this reply […]

Add a comment


Katya Fisher Yoffe

Katya Fisher Yoffe is recipient of the Howard M. Squadron Fellowship in Law, Media, and Society at the Programme in Comparative Media Law and Policy, University of Oxford and a law student at Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law. She is editor of which is being developed in conjunction with the National Endowment for Democracy's Center for International Media Assistance and The Center for Global Communication Studies at the Annenberg School for Communication. Katya has worked as a legal intern at the Open Society Justice Initiative, the Art Loss Register, and the Art Law Department of Herrick, Feinstein LLP. Prior to attending law school Katya worked in communications in Moscow, Russia. On a lighter note, she is also the editor/writer of BlackBook Media's Guide to Moscow. Katya is a graduate of New York University.

GreadDecisions in foreign policy discussion group ad v2