Comments on: India's Baloch dilemma http://foreignpolicyblogs.com/2009/07/20/indias-baloch-dilemma/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=indias-baloch-dilemma The FPA Global Affairs Blog Network Wed, 22 Feb 2012 18:29:30 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Siddharth http://foreignpolicyblogs.com/2009/07/20/indias-baloch-dilemma/#comment-3395 Siddharth Sun, 03 Apr 2011 11:01:48 +0000 http://india.foreignpolicyblogs.com/?p=59#comment-3395 Hi Sultan, First of all I would like to reply you. As an Indian and looking at the conditions of nations in subcontinet; I think muslims are at the safest place in India. They are prosperous than other nationS; not intimidated my majority (except some instances; which can happen in any country with that much diversity). Acrocities have happened with Hindus and other religions too in India; it doesn't mean that we would leve oUr secular nature. Some radical elemnts are there in every society. It is true with Pak muslims too. They are being targeted by radical elements there. In India too, there are extremist at both end but it doesn't mean that we should stop believing in our system. I wonder....why the people like you could never think that in spite of having whopping 80% Hindu population; India could never have a Hindu nationalistic party rule ????? Why BJP cannot get majority in parliament on the basis of "Hindu Nation Theory" in spite of having 80% population ???? Because the majority in India still believes in secularism that that majority includes more Hindus than Muslims . Muslims are getting more than equal opportunity in India (they are geeting reservations under minority quota); we had a muslim president who made us proud. If still muslims lag in progress chart; upto certain extent they should blame themselves too and do an introspection. Governament or majority in India have never stopped them to be prosperous......it only the matter of time when they would realize their rights in India and contribute more in nation's growth story. I am not sure what motivates your thought process but would request you to please do a reality check before posting your thoughts about the conditions of muslims in India over internet. I would like to assure rest of the world and all the readers who raed this blog that our muslim brothers are as safe in India s they are in any other Islamic republic and sometimes safer too. Regards, Sid. Hi Sultan,

First of all I would like to reply you. As an Indian and looking at the conditions of nations in subcontinet; I think muslims are at the safest place in India. They are prosperous than other nationS; not intimidated my majority (except some instances; which can happen in any country with that much diversity). Acrocities have happened with Hindus and other religions too in India; it doesn’t mean that we would leve oUr secular nature.

Some radical elemnts are there in every society. It is true with Pak muslims too. They are being targeted by radical elements there. In India too, there are extremist at both end but it doesn’t mean that we should stop believing in our system. I wonder….why the people like you could never think that in spite of having whopping 80% Hindu population; India could never have a Hindu nationalistic party rule ????? Why BJP cannot get majority in parliament on the basis of “Hindu Nation Theory” in spite of having 80% population ???? Because the majority in India still believes in secularism that that majority includes more Hindus than Muslims .

Muslims are getting more than equal opportunity in India (they are geeting reservations under minority quota); we had a muslim president who made us proud. If still muslims lag in progress chart; upto certain extent they should blame themselves too and do an introspection. Governament or majority in India have never stopped them to be prosperous……it only the matter of time when they would realize their rights in India and contribute more in nation’s growth story.

I am not sure what motivates your thought process but would request you to please do a reality check before posting your thoughts about the conditions of muslims in India over internet. I would like to assure rest of the world and all the readers who raed this blog that our muslim brothers are as safe in India s they are in any other Islamic republic and sometimes safer too.

Regards,
Sid.

]]> By: Why a nuclear deal for Pakistan is a bad idea | India http://foreignpolicyblogs.com/2009/07/20/indias-baloch-dilemma/#comment-3394 Why a nuclear deal for Pakistan is a bad idea | India Wed, 24 Mar 2010 15:15:49 +0000 http://india.foreignpolicyblogs.com/?p=59#comment-3394 [...] rallies’ held by Hizbul Mujahideen and Jamaatud Dawa. Instead it has blamed India for interfering in Balochistan, and wanting to disintegrate Pakistan. By dealing with General Kayani the US has also undermined [...] [...] rallies’ held by Hizbul Mujahideen and Jamaatud Dawa. Instead it has blamed India for interfering in Balochistan, and wanting to disintegrate Pakistan. By dealing with General Kayani the US has also undermined [...]

]]> By: Sultan http://foreignpolicyblogs.com/2009/07/20/indias-baloch-dilemma/#comment-3393 Sultan Sat, 27 Feb 2010 08:54:58 +0000 http://india.foreignpolicyblogs.com/?p=59#comment-3393 I feel now that India should try to save itself rather than work on its old 'Akhand Bharat' theory. India played its role in Afghanistan and Balochistan. But now indian allies are packing up from Afghanistan means the end of indian role in Afghanistan. The last 10 years of Afghanistan makes Pakistan to believe that US is not friend of Pakistan and India is true enemy that can not accept Pakistan existance. This same keeps Pakistan very close to China. I'm indian muslim and still love india but the muslim plight in India makes me feel that our ancestors were wrong to believe in secularism. But now Pakistan is very close to China in Indian enmity. I feel now that India should try to save itself rather than work on its old ‘Akhand Bharat’ theory. India played its role in Afghanistan and Balochistan. But now indian allies are packing up from Afghanistan means the end of indian role in Afghanistan.
The last 10 years of Afghanistan makes Pakistan to believe that US is not friend of Pakistan and India is true enemy that can not accept Pakistan existance. This same keeps Pakistan very close to China.
I’m indian muslim and still love india but the muslim plight in India makes me feel that our ancestors were wrong to believe in secularism.
But now Pakistan is very close to China in Indian enmity.

]]> By: Hassan Rastar http://foreignpolicyblogs.com/2009/07/20/indias-baloch-dilemma/#comment-3392 Hassan Rastar Sat, 16 Jan 2010 12:04:45 +0000 http://india.foreignpolicyblogs.com/?p=59#comment-3392 pakistan is one of our greatest enemies of the world. we will welcome all sort of support from the indian government and people and wish that they will support us in near future. the indian govt should carry out a severe onslaught on pakisan and capture the capital of pakistan. we, the baloch support india in this regard. thanks, Hassan Rastar. pakistan is one of our greatest enemies of the world. we will welcome all sort of support from the indian government and people and wish that they will support us in near future.
the indian govt should carry out a severe onslaught on pakisan and capture the capital of pakistan.
we, the baloch support india in this regard.
thanks,
Hassan Rastar.

]]> By: Baloch http://foreignpolicyblogs.com/2009/07/20/indias-baloch-dilemma/#comment-3391 Baloch Wed, 14 Oct 2009 07:56:28 +0000 http://india.foreignpolicyblogs.com/?p=59#comment-3391 India should support Baloch people for the Freedom Of Balochistan that is occupied by terrorist country Pakistan in March 27, 1948 after the Declaration of Balochistan Freedom. Long Live Baloch Liberation Movement. Down With PAki Army and pakistan India should support Baloch people for the Freedom Of Balochistan that is occupied by terrorist country Pakistan in March 27, 1948 after the Declaration of Balochistan Freedom.
Long Live Baloch Liberation Movement.
Down With PAki Army and pakistan

]]> By: Balochistan Economic Importance And BLA Role as Mercenary — Pro Pakistan http://foreignpolicyblogs.com/2009/07/20/indias-baloch-dilemma/#comment-3390 Balochistan Economic Importance And BLA Role as Mercenary — Pro Pakistan Sun, 16 Aug 2009 09:54:51 +0000 http://india.foreignpolicyblogs.com/?p=59#comment-3390 [...] means destabilizing the whole Pakistani economy. The Indian are well aware of this fact. The Indian Foreign Policy Blog states the following in one of its [...] [...] means destabilizing the whole Pakistani economy. The Indian are well aware of this fact. The Indian Foreign Policy Blog states the following in one of its [...]

]]> By: Pakistani Objections « Subcontinental Breakfast http://foreignpolicyblogs.com/2009/07/20/indias-baloch-dilemma/#comment-3389 Pakistani Objections « Subcontinental Breakfast Thu, 23 Jul 2009 07:05:59 +0000 http://india.foreignpolicyblogs.com/?p=59#comment-3389 [...] plugging Balochistan into the mix after all these years? (Manasi Kakatkar actually has some pretty good points on why Singh might’ve agreed to this.) And there were plenty of repercussions to that [...] [...] plugging Balochistan into the mix after all these years? (Manasi Kakatkar actually has some pretty good points on why Singh might’ve agreed to this.) And there were plenty of repercussions to that [...]

]]>