Foreign Policy Blogs

The U.N. Lacks Moral Authority to Dictate Morale in Haiti

 

Photo: Latimes

Photo: Latimes

It is a volcano jumping between dormant and active stages and last month, it erupted again, spitting a litany of condemning editorials across global opinion pages that set ablaze United Nations’ inexcusable, uncompromising policy in Haiti, where the cholera epidemic, now entering its fourth year, killed more than 8,300 people and sickened another 650,000. An advocacy group representing the victims provoked the latest upsurge of Haiti’s cholera fiasco when it filed a lawsuit against the U.N. in a Manhattan Federal District Court, demanding reparations.

Although an Everest of evidence only indexed U.N. peacekeepers, particularly a Nepalese contingent caught dumping human waste into the Artibonite River near its base that numerous studies pinned at the origin of the outbreak, the global organization refused to accept responsibility for its man-made disaster. However, lead counsel Mario Joseph hopes this eruption will spew enough lava to overwhelm U.N. officials’ deniability and compel them to pay financial reparations to its victims.

The U.N.’s response to the lawsuit varied little from its persisting refrain; a confluence of circumstances, including the country’s dearth of clean water and good sanitation facilitated the spread of cholera. Beyond its dismissive, dehumanizing response however, the global entity failed to provide a shred of scientific evidence, challenging the slew of academic research that traced the cholera strain to Nepal that experienced an outbreak in the months preceding its peacekeepers’ deployment to Haiti.

Photo- CBS News

Photo- CBS News

Rather than taking necessary safety measures to protect hundreds of thousands of lives, the U.N. neglected to properly screen its troops, failed to maintain proper sanitation facilities, and take immediate, appropriate actions following the outbreak. It therefore carelessly allowed Haitians to become infected with cholera, unheard of in the Caribbean nation since 1867. Instead, organizational leaders hid behind the 1946 Convention of the Privileges and Immunities of the United Nations, claiming absolute immunity from prosecution, spitting on the graves and faces of its victims.

Photo: conservativefiringline.com

Photo: conservativefiringline.com

Asked about an official response to the lawsuit, “it is not the United Nations practice to discuss in public claims filed against the Organization,” answered a U.N. spokesperson. Yet, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon telephoned President Michel Martelly in February 2013 and told him that the U.N. would not compensate any of the 5,000 claimants the Institute for Justice and Democracy (IJDH) represented in a similar November 2011 lawsuit. As Joseph argued, “The United Nations can’t have humanity and impunity at the same time,” which was a pivotal conclusion researchers from Yale Law School reached last July, after examining the cholera debacle. The report noted the United Nations’ immunity clause does not confer absolute impunity, especially when the world organization blatantly violated its contractual obligations to Haiti and its responsibilities under international human rights law. In its signed-agreement with the Haitian government when it established a peacekeeping force there in 2004, the U.N. promised to create a commission to review claims related to complaints about its troops. Such a commission has never been established, noted the report.

U.N.’s degrading response to its victims’ public outcry constituted not only an attack on human dignity and decency, but also a violation of fundamental accountability principles that has govern society for millennia. As such, we must stop punishing poorly behaving children; intervene in countries where totalitarian regimes use chemical weapons on their own people; or, for that fact, administer justice to individuals that, through criminal negligence, allow others to die.

The Yale report correctly stated, the U.N. “risks losing its moral ground by refusing to comply with the very law it demands states and other international actors to respect,” and I could not agree more, especially when the rising tide of anti-Martelly demonstrations inhibiting the country could necessitate peacekeepers’ intervention. Granted, the United Nations played a pivotal role, helping save and/or improve lives in Haiti, particularly in the country’s post-quake struggles; nevertheless, human lives must supersede self-serving bureaucratic, political or policy maneuvers.

 
  • FyshGrrL Elizabeth

    To claim immunity from prosecution in the face of gross negligence is the ultimate in hubris. It suggests the U.N. has entirely lost sight of its humanitarian mission and functions only as muscle to ensure political stability. The fact that the personnel transfer that triggered this outbreak occurred 10 months after the chaos of the quake is relevant, too. This was not an error made in the throes of an emergency. It was administrative laziness of the worst sort – It is gross negligence to take personnel from an active epidemic area and move them WITHOUT REGARD for their status as potential carriers of cholera. We all know the rest. What possible reason is there for excusing this, when the UN managed to spend $640+ million in Haiti last year WITHOUT addressing cholera AT ALL?

    • Chris

      Thank for reading and commenting Elizabeth. You’re absolutely correct in your comment. There are very few countries on earth where the UN can act in such a manner and get away with it. Even more outrageous, the UN has been in Haiti for 10 years and has yet to help fix the water sanitation problem that exacerbated the cholera epidemic that’s still affecting the population.

Author

Chris Celius
Chris Celius

Currently residing in Charlotte, NC, Chris Celius obtained his BA in public relations and journalism at the UNC Charlotte where he is currently pursuing his maters in Communication Studies. Emigrated from Haiti to the United States in the 90s, Chris shares a passion for writing that both insightful and edifying.

americasdiplomats_socialmediaasset